Tuesday, December 9, 2008

Philippine banks to declare bank holidays?

Two banks, the Philippine Countryside Development Bank and the Philippine Rural Banks all based in Cebu have collapsed and declared a bank holiday today. Sources inside the banking industry says, expect other small and medium-sized banks especially those based in Southern Luzon and some parts of the North to collapse as well. Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) reportedly had an advance information about this that's why yesterday, the Philippine Deposit Insurance Corporation decided to raise the insurance of bank deposits to as high as 500,000 pesos.

As I wrote some months ago, the weakest link in the Philippine banking industry is the rural banks. As the economy slows, with weak demands from both Metro Manila and foreign countries, expect the death of export industries based in the provinces. Local demands cannot support huge production of export and agri industrial products from the rural areas. Low demands lead to low production. With slower economic activity, definitely companies and entrepreneurs will find it very hard to pay off debts and loans.

Another bad news---the government failed to "liquify" or "monetize" 30 billion pesos worth of bad housing mortgages. Sources say, government has absorbed more than 66 billion pesos worth of bad housing mortgages and last November, has failed to attract bidders or buyers. Apparently, what we are seeing is the first embers of a smoldering Philippine sub-prime mortgage crisis. And government, it seems, is quite helpless.

Does this concern us? Yes, because the National Housing MOrtgage Finance Corporation will need to get more money from Pag-Ibig, GSIS and SSS to plug the financial hemorrhage. Since funds from these governing financial institutions will be redirected to support NHMFC, this means longer loan processing times and possibly disapproval for loan applications from SSS, GSIS and PAGIBIG members.

If this government agency collapses, this will affect all real estate projects in the country. A collapse will mean a domino effect on almost all critical sectors in the economy, leading to a very abrupt recession. Market analysts have not factored this issue in, obviously because they are afraid to create panic. But, I tell you now, this issue is really very very serious to warrant immediate planning and plugging holes by Malacanang. Otherwise, our financial and economic situation might worsen leading to negative growth.

Another issue---sources say the BSP is injecting more and more dollars into the Forex market to stabilize the peso. The local currency is under extreme attack from speculators. Sources say the peso-dollar exchange will reach 56 by 2009.

Net of discussion--there seems to be no government plan to at least mitigate the full effects of a bank run or bank holidays in the coming months. Analysts say, it's expected, since government cannot really insulate the banking sector from the creeping global financial crisis. The question I pose is--will government reserves be enough to pump prime the banking sector? The World Bank advised the BSP to at least expand its credit facilities and lower interest rates. Will the BSP follow suit? Latest talk says BSP's Tetangco is adverse to the idea. So, my friends, expect a further tightening of credit markets and veritable bank runs and holidays in the coming weeks.

11 comments:

  1. As you are saying, these are not bank holidays, these are bank-ruptcies

    A bank holiday is the temporary closing of a bank in the event that its obligations exceed its resources, says Cebu Online News.
    (Philippine Countryside Rural Bank in Cebu declares ‘bank holiday’
    Dec 9th, 2008 |
    http://www.cebuonlinenews.com/20081209/992169-philippine-countryside-rural-bank-in-cebu-declares-bank-holiday/ )

    Under that definition, EVERY bank is on holiday. No bank has 100 percent reserves for its deposits. That’s what fractional-reserve banking is about.

    Detroit had an extraordinary growth in the boom of the 1920s with the rapid development of the AUTOMOBILE industry (ANONYMOUS: sounds familiar these days).
    Real estate values had mounted rapidly and credit against real estate had increased greatly. (ANONYMOUS: sounds familiar these days in the US).
    Too much of this credit had got into the banks themselves. Moreover, there had been a particularly aggressive “group bank" movement centering in Detroit and moving out into Michigan.
    The stock of the holding company of this group had gone to fantastic levels and had had altogether too much bank credit put behind it.
    The Detroit banking situation was vulnerable
    On March 5, 1933, US President Franklin Delano Roosevelt declared a "bank holiday", which, for four days forced the closure of the nation's banks and halted all financial transactions.
    (Benjamin M. Anderson, “Economics and the Public Welfare – A Financial and Economic History of the United States, 1914-46”, Indianapolis, Liberty Press, 1979, 2nd ed., (first ed. published in 1949 by D. Van Nostrand Company), pp. 285-286)

    That’s something else than Cebu 2008.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Radio dzMM said the Philippine Countryside Rural Bank in Cebu made the announcement after the Supreme Court ruled last week that the financial institution had an “undercapitalization.” (1)

    The central bank, Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP), [last week] scored a victory against a group of rural banks that regulators have tried—but failed—to close down last year for being capital deficient. (2)

    What does that mean "capital deficiency"?

    Is that deficiency vis-à-vis 100 percent reserve for the deposits?

    Or deficiency vis-à-vis the legal requirements?

    ANONYMOUS

    (1)
    Cebu bank declares ‘holiday’--report
    INQUIRER.net
    First Posted 11:28:00 12/09/2008
    http://business.inquirer.net/money/breakingnews/view/20081209-176935/Cebu-bank-declares-holiday--report

    (2)
    High court favors BSP vs Legacy banks
    By Daxim Lucas
    Philippine Daily Inquirer
    First Posted 04:04:00 12/02/2008
    http://business.inquirer.net/money/topstories/view/20081202-175577/High-court-favors-BSP-vs-Legacy-banks

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks. Aactually, there are now 150 banks under a big banking group which are "undercapitalized"

    ReplyDelete
  4. i'm very concerned with this issue because i am a client of the Philippine Rural Banking Corporation. I was alarmed, really. However, contrary to your posted article, the banks that declared bank holidays were the Philippine Countryside Rural Bank and Pilipino Rural Bank Inc. as reported in the Inquirer today. I was relieved when I read the news.

    I made inquiries with the officers of my bank and apparently, they are not troubled by the looming financial crisis. They made it clear that the Philippine Rural Banking Corporation is NOT declaring a bank holiday. Please rectify the name of the bank in your article because I am sure that you have stirred anxiety among the depositors of PR Bank (the one Isabela), like me.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Jeni,

    Well, as predicted by this site, other banks followed suit which belongs to the Legacy Group of Companies, a company allegedly headed by Albay Mayor Celso de los Angeles.

    And yes, it was Pilipino Rural Bank not, Philippine Rural Bank.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Fractional-reserve banking
    From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking
    SNIP
    Fractional-reserve banking is the banking practice in which banks are required to keep only a fraction of their deposits in reserve with the choice of lending out the remainder while maintaining the obligation to redeem all deposits upon demand. This practice is UNIVERSAL in modern banking.

    Criticism of fractional-reserve banking
    From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
    (Redirected from Debt-based monetary system)
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt-based_monetary_system
    SNIPS
    Some critics of fractional reserve banking and the related monetary system may refer to it by the political term debt-based monetary system
    +
    Critics of fractional reserve usually note that the banking system “creates money out of nothing”. The insight that banks “create money by extending loans” is not new, and the subject is covered in most introductory economics textbooks and many popular reference works

    Banking industry remains robust–BSP
    Written by Jun Vallecera & Butch Fernandez / Reporters
    Friday, 12 December 2008 02:05
    http://businessmirror.com.ph/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=3252:banking-industry-remains-robustbsp&catid=25:bankingandfinance&Itemid=61
    SNIP
    REFUSING to comment on rural banks that belong to the Legacy Group that declared a unilateral bank holiday and another that was placed by the Monetary Board under receivership, the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) said on Thursday the banking industry remains robust and resilient.
    Deputy Governor Diwa Guinigundo said the underlying elements that make the banking system go remain in place although some smaller units may be falling apart.

    Something Like Life: No stopping Christmas
    Written by Ma. Stella F. Arnaldo(stella-arnaldo.blogspot.com)
    Friday, 12 December 2008 00:50
    http://businessmirror.com.ph/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=3229:something-like-life-no-stopping-christmas&catid=32:life&Itemid=68
    SNIP
    While the Bangko Sentral and the local banks continue to reassure us of the soundness of the banking system, small savers like me can’t help but still feel a bit unsure.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Bank Runs in the Philippines
    Thursday, December 11, 2008
    http://bullioninsider.blogspot.com/2008/12/bank-runs-in-philippines.html
    SNIP
    Herein lies the problem with fractional reserve banking...they only keep a fraction on reserve to cover deposits. If more than 10% of depositors attempt the pull out their money, there will not be any left for them. It is for this reason the FDIC is a major confidence game. The FDIC has less than 1% on reserves against total deposits. My advice? Only keep in the banks what you can afford to lose....

    ReplyDelete
  8. The BSP reiterated that the closed banks represented a tiny FRACTION of the banking system and that the Philippine banking system remained stable, highly capitalized and highly liquid.

    ( 3 more rural banks padlocked
    By Doris Dumlao
    Philippine Daily Inquirer
    First Posted 04:30:00 12/13/2008
    http://business.inquirer.net/money/topstories/view/20081213-177768/3-more-rural-banks-padlocked )

    ReplyDelete
  9. [Central bank Governor Amando] Tetangco [Jr] said the Philippine banking system is sound and adequately capitalized, at levels above the Bank of International Settlement standard of 8 percent and the central bank’s regulatory requirement of 10 percent.

    (BSP pushes for ‘stronger authority’ over banks
    Manila Times – Philippines
    Monday, December 15, 2008 http://www.manilatimes.net/national/2008/dec/15/yehey/top_stories/20081215top3.html )

    ReplyDelete
  10. Philippine Depositor Insurance Corporation (PDIC), in a press conference Tuesday, assured depositors that they will get their deposits back. But as to when, the PDIC could still not give the rural bank clients a time frame for it.

    (PDIC assures worried depositors of 'closed' rural banks in Cebu
    By CARINE M. ASUTILLA, ABS-CBN News Central Visayas | 12/16/2008 11:35 PM
    http://www.abs-cbnnews.com/nation/regions/12/16/08/pdic-assures-worried-depositors-closed-rural-banks-cebu )

    ReplyDelete
  11. METROBANK IN TROUBLE ... IN HK

    They are keeping quiet ... but heard from reliable sources in hk that Metrobank's fully owned subsidiary in hk, first metro international investment company limited, was raided by hk police in december 2008 with search warrants. Arrest warrants were issued for its officers who are out on bail. The company was closed down in Dec 2008 after metrobank gave up the license because of violations found in audits by HK monetary authorities. The poor filipinos in Hk are still remitting their money through metrobank (which owns another remittance company in hk) without knowing how risky it is. Lazy and corrupt philippine banking regulators are not doing their job ... they are just busy attending parties given by bankers.

    Filipino depositors are surely not in good hands with Metrobank.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you very much for reading my blog. You inspired me. But if you intend to put your name "anonymous", better not comment at all. Thanks!