Showing posts with label the supreme court of the philippines. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the supreme court of the philippines. Show all posts

Thursday, March 15, 2012

Renato Corona, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Philippines


He sits alone in his mahogany dining table, eating crispy chicken skin, when we left him. An hour before, he looked frail and weak, like he’s not eaten in weeks. Though he cast an imposing figure, his green barong cannot hide one singular fact—the Chief Justice has lost weight. He silently limbers around his office, which looks ordinary for a distinguished lawyer like him, except that, at the middle of this office, bears the mighty Seal of the Supreme Court. That seal is above his black leather chair and table. Unlike any other though, instead of sofa seats, his dining table fronts his office table. I wonder how many people have eaten in that table, which can easily dine ten people at one time. And I wonder how many times the Chief Justice has shared his passion for lechong manok, and of course, crispy chicken skin.


This office does not look like a place for a beleaguered man, I told myself, as I perused hundreds of books which adorn his office. Months ago, he was pilloried by his counterpart and accused of being a hindrance to this government’s alleged “tuwid na daan”. He has since then, been kicked, punched, and spit at his face, his family threatened and his very self exposed nakedly for all the whole world to see.

Any Batangueno worth his worth would have gotten his bolo or even cocked his gun. Any lesser man would have gotten one of his 31 guns in his armoury and shoot the lights off his detractors, he being a former straight shooter like his counterpart. But no.

Renato Corona, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Philippines, is no butangero. He does not lose his cool. Fact is, he’s even proud of telling people that he rarely loses his composure. “Ever since this happened”, says Corona, “ I have never thought of taking revenge. Ask my wife. Ask my kids. There has never been an instance where I thought evil against any man. I was not raised by my parents to be vengeful, oh no. I am proud of being a Corona. I am proud of my family’s legacy to this country.”

“ When I was young, I used to love guns. I was a gun shooter. I competed in several competitions. I had a passion for it. However, when I aged, the passion for practical shooting hit me less and less. Now, I don’t love it anymore. “

What had happened that transformed this man, from a gun lover to an advocate of peace? Without battling an eyelash, Corona says, it is his love for the law. And God. 

Ever since he was a kid, Renato Corona had always aspired to be a lawyer. His forebears were land surveyors. He was raised comfortably by his parents. Of course, he’s not a Cojuangco, but he was never the man Malacanang pictured him to be---a poor, struggling one who only enriched himself when he entered public service.

“ I am proud of my heritage. I am proud of the service my forebears brought to this country. Fact is, go to Mandaluyong, and you’ll find a street named after my grandfather.”

Corona was equally proud of his wife, Cristina Basa. He shared with us, his wife’s family heritage. Her great grandfather, Jose Maria Basa, was the financier of the 1896 Revolution. Prior to Bonifacio, Basa was the Katipunan Supremo. When the Spaniards discovered the revolt, Basa was one of those who were exiled abroad, and had to surrender several thousand hectares of his property to the state. Yet, he never complained. Basa was a patriot, says Corona, and he’s proud that that same blood runs through the veins of his lovely wife.

When someone asked why the Basas now want his head, Corona just shrugs and says that that was not his fight. The Basas and the Guidotes had that fight long ago, and he was just dragged into it because he’s Cristina’s husband. The Basas suspected that he used or is using his vast network to influence the cases. Corona denies any allegation, saying that if he did, those cases pending before the courts of Manila would have been resolved a long time ago.

He, Renato Corona, is such a man, a man of integrity and character. He does not lose his temper. He claims never to have lifted a finger against any man. Yet, like any other, he also feels bad against some, even his closest of friends, but never ever thought of using his powers to get back at them.

When I asked him about Associate Justice Antonio Carpio if they are still buddies, Corona had this to say: “ No, we are not anymore buddies. We are just civil to each other. Each member of this court is learned, each civilized. I don’t harbour any grudge against any of them. Of course, I feel bad, but feelings aside, I don’t feel revenge.”

Corona and Carpio, many of my lawyer friends say, were the best of friends. They both served during the time of former president Fidel Valdes Ramos, Carpio being appointed as Chief Legal Counsel while Corona served as a Deputy Executive Secretary for Legal Concerns. It was during the time of Ramos that both started their careers in public service and both flourished.

Sick with tonsilitis but I'm a fool if I'll pass
this chance to interview the controversial
Chief Justice
Several close in associates say that the two became estranged shortly after an internal investigation conducted by Malacanang found one of them guilty of using his influence to affect the Fraport case. That Fraport case was the one which  broke the strong ties of Carpio and Corona. Both of these gentlemen respected each other, especially Corona who even considered Carpio as a brother. After Fraport and that very public severing of ties between Carpio’s law firm and the Arroyo administration, Corona and Carpio had rarely spoken to each other.

Was Fraport really the cause behind these latest efforts to dislodge Corona from his seat as Chief Justice? As punishment, the Arroyos reportedly vowed to block Carpio’s ascension to the Chief Justice seat, something which, when I asked Corona about, he was tight lipped. He says:

“ Even if that happened, no one would corroborate that. You know, in government, and I have stayed for so long in government, these things, even if it did happen, no one would be brave enough to admit that it did happen.”

So, why is he being castigated by this administration which is reportedly very close to the Firm, that law office founded by Carpio in 1981?

Corona propounded four reasons, one of which is the oft-repeated line of Hacienda Luisita. The other, he says, is the fear of a close Aquino buddy that he will influence the pending electoral case before the Supreme Court questioning the election of the Vice President and third, he is perceived to be a stumbling block to the interests of some groups which he did not identify. And the fourth, he’s perceived closeness to the former dispensation.

“ The fourth one is the one that truly troubles me. I am just being dragged into this mess. They have a beef against the former administration, why drag me into it? Probably, if only some people there in Malacanang really knows me, they will not consider me an enemy. I am just collateral damage here, “ says Corona who was appointed by former president and now suspect in numerous criminal cases, Gloria Arroyo.

(Part II: Issues and the Shakedown")

Friday, December 16, 2011

Dictatorship and efforts at claiming the Courts for the people

Justice secretary Leila de Lima says President Noynoy Aquino is determined to "reclaim the court to the people". Question---who are the "people" that De Lima claims owns the Court?


Clearly, the Constitution says the People is the "Filipino people". So, now, what kind of claim will Noynoy and his political allies do? 


De Lima did not elaborate. This opens this issue to doubt. How can the Executive claim the Court, when in the Constitution, the Court is definitely independent of the Executive?


How will the Executive claim what is definitely not theirs in the first place? It is not the Chief Executive that will claim the Court "for and in behalf of the People" because theoretically, he is not the only representative of the People. 


Besides, the Chief Executive has a different interpretation of the "people". His people may be his closest allies, those who control major companies in this country. It may be his "people" are those who occupy the palace or his "people" may also be his supporters.


This is problematic, because what the Constitution defines the people is the mass of individuals composing this Republican state. Who has the plurality of voice, but the Legislative?


If someone wants to claim the Judiciary or the Courts, he must do it thru the Legislature, not thru the police powers of the Executive nor thru machinations.


Is De Lima suggesting that mob rule dominates reason or the Law? That is not what Noynoy intends to do. The Chief Executive wants to cleanse the judiciary of misfits like Chief Justice Renato Corona. And there is a process of doing it, and it is thru the impeachment process.


Now, if the Chief Executive fails to see thru with this impeachment, this will boomerang against him---politically.


What this issue right now is doing is giving the political enemies of this administration, a venue and an opportunity to consolidate their forces against Aquino.


Former UP law dean Raul Pangalangan says that efforts right now are directed at Corona and two other justices because, for the longest time, the Court has not exercised what the Constitution calls for, that is, a court with an "impartial judge".


How will the people trust this institution of governance when the very head of this branch of government, thru his overt acts, shows his partiality and total dogged allegiance to the former dispensation?


Chief justice Corona is not fighting for the independence of the Supreme Court, no. He is fighting for his political survival. He is agitating people and trying to portray the Court as "unassailable".


The Supreme Court has no real power, except those given by the people. It is the people's trust and confidence that fuels or makes its decisions "unassailable". It is the people's trust that makes its decisions acceptable.


If the Supreme Court, in its litany of decisions, always side with a clique in this society's elites, then, it cannot claim to be oppressed when the very same decisions that make it as it is, are the same ones that condemn it?


Who then is the dictator here? The one who wants nothing more than save the Judiciary from its present rut so that the confidence and trust of the people would be restored?


Or someone who wants nothing more than make this Court always hallowed ground for those who robbed the people of billions and prostituted the very voice of the People?







Thursday, December 15, 2011

Corona declares war against Pnoy: says he's primus inter pares of the Supreme Court

Corona proudly proclaims hebeing the Court's Primus Inter Pares
Primus inter pares is always that Latin phrase that animates a law student's conversations with friends. Freshmen knows it first that's why they include it in their banter. It is like something very new and very novel to the ears of those who heard it for the first time, that it is used to distinguish those who truly study and love the study of the Law from those who do not.

In not quite a few times, law students try to be the first among equals. They mock their friends, and join fraternities to be "first among equals". That said, this Latin phrase has become one of the most common terms uttered during challenges. And that's how Chief Justice Renato Corona spiced his speech up yesterday that he, indeed, is the primus inter pares of the Court.
There is no doubt about it--Corona is the highest among the justices, being appointed during a time of great difficulty and under a cloud of doubt. Before, fresh from his appointment as CJ by Gloria, many questions his status as primus inter pares, foremost is President Benigno S. Aquino III.

For the sake of unity, the People gave Corona the right and privilege of being the Court's first born son. Yet, it doesn't mean that Corona is not accountable to the people, oh no.

It doesn't mean that Corona has every right not to submit his SALN. It doesn't mean that Corona 's whims and caprices are tolerated and considered acceptable behavior of the Court's Highest Monarch. And it doesn't mean that Corona would just stomp his feet and use his powers to protect his principal, the former president Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo.

And really now, it does not mean that Corona would just do whatever he wants to do of the billions of pesos worth of the Court's budget.

In his speech, Corona asked why the President always try to hit him. Corona probably thought that Noynoy had a personal grudge on him or that Aquino had bad feelings towards him.

That reveals the true nature of Corona---a person who thinks that another one's hit against him is always personal. No.

Aquino and his allies hit him because of what he did---his record of voting is always in favor of Gloria. For the 19 or so cases he reviewed, he always favor his principal.

He transformed the Supreme Court into his own personal turf, something abominable to say the least.

He even turned the Judiciary into a refuge and sanctuary of those who robbed and stole big-time during the nine long years of the Arroyo regime.

Before, during Martial Law, the Supreme Court got the highest approval and trust ratings from the people, because it opposed Marcos and became the sanctuary of freedom fighters.

Now, the Court has been prostituted and became the sanctuary of those who tried to kill freedom and democracy in this country by bamboozling the elections, prostituting the voice and will of the people and wantonly turned the public coffers into their personal bank.

It is really not important who is first among equals. If you are first by title only, your boasts are empty.

But when you are first among equals, and has shown that you deserve to be first, then, the people will shower you with honors and accollates you'll never ask.

Besides, it is not being first that is important---it is being TRUE and HONEST and being worthy of initiating CHANGE.

What is so worthy of showing canine-like behavior? Is that what you call the first among equals?

The real First among equals is those who serve, not those who think that they should be served.

Wednesday, December 7, 2011

President Noynoy Aquino's rants against the Supreme Court

So-called legal experts have been commenting negatively about President Noynoy's remarks against the Supreme Court Chief Justice. They think that those statements were uncalled for and "disturbing", coming from the head of a co-equal branch of government. But, what is so wrong with asking the Chief Justice to at least hear the position of the government and turn his post the way the Constitution intended the court to be--an impartial judge?


Among the constitutional bodies of government, the Supreme Court enjoys the least trust and confidence from the people. And why so? Because there is a perception that this Court has been politicized already by the people behind the previous dispensation.


What is so wrong with asking this Chief Justice to at least be cooperative with the government's current efforts to cleanse the bureaucracy of misfits and grafters?


What is so wrong with pleading with this Chief Justice to stop playing politics and instead focus on really applying the Spirit of our laws instead of considering your links with the former First Couple?


For a democracy to continue working, the system must have an Executive branch dancing in tango with the Judiciary and the Legislative departments.


If the Executive is the only branch that is pursuing a reform agenda and the two other branches lag behind, then, what will happen to us?